The Social Network/The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2010/2011)
Composer: Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross
Number of tracks: 19/39
Total times: 66:11/173:30
Overview:
David Fincher... for those in the know, the name probably brings up scenes from some of the most dark and depressing films of the last 19 years. Fincher first appeared on the directing scene with the much troubled third installment of the Alien series, Alien3 (1992) before moving on to direct such films as Se7en (1995) , Fight Club (1999), Panic Room (2002), Zodiac (2007) and The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (2008).
Along the way, Fincher has worked with some of the top film score composers of the Digital Age including Elliot Goldenthal (1), Howard Shore (3), David Shire (1) and Alexandre Desplat (1). In 2009, Fincher finally found his musical muse in Trent Reznor, ex-front man of the rock group Nine Inch Nails. Fincher has always leaned more towards dark, ambient scores for his films even when fully orchestral (Benjamin Button is the lone exception), so the experimental "sound design" of Reznor's work fit perfectly into the directors idea of film music.
So far, Reznor has done two scores for Fincher: The Social Network (2010, Academy Award winner) and The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2011). Today, I will briefly review both works in one fell swoop.
The Social Network review:
For those that might still be in the dark about this film, Social Network tells the (partly fictional) account of the birth of Facebook and all the trials of Mark Zuckerburg. The film is an interesting character study and is actually rather engaging, though also rather depressing, as most of Fincher's work is. The music on the other hand, is a vastly different story....
The album opens with "Hand Covers Bruise" which consists of what sounds like a razor being scraped over strings as a sparse piano piece plays. A low 3-note bass motif appears between performances of the piano piece. After this stark intro, the remaining music is divided between oddly retro sounding 80's synth textures and grungy experimental rock pieces that sound like leftover ideas from Hans Zimmer's Joker material in The Dark Knight (2008).
Oddly enough, there are some enjoyable pieces on the album: "In Motion", "Painted Sun Abstract", "In the Hall of the Mountain King" and "Soft Trees Break Fall" are actually somewhat enjoyable, even if they are rather repetitive and not something you want to listen to if your depressed, especially "Soft Trees...". On the other hand, the rest of the album is rubbish. Probably the worse offender being "A Familiar Taste" which sounds like some of the edgy grunge rock music Paul Haslinger is so fond of in his Underworld scores.
Really, the worst thing about The Social Network is the fact that there is no sense of any of this music being a connected whole or fitting the films narrative flow. There are no themes or motifs to follow and even the overall mood of the album varies so wildly that it becomes more of a collection of various songs rather than a cohesive score. This is only compounded by the fact that the majority of the music is rather annoying and sounds like a bunch of kids let loose in a studio with synths and electric guitars....
How on earth this work won the Best Original Score Oscar is beyond me, as there were plenty of other great scores nominated that year.
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo review:
Despite the insipid nature of the previous Trent Reznor "score", Fincher hired him again for his next film: The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. The film follows a newspaper reporter and a computer hacker as they try to uncover corruption in Sweden and find more than they were expecting. The film is disturbingly violent, bleak and overall unpleasant... the perfect breeding ground for Reznor's tortured "sound design" way of scoring.
Reznor approached this project by recording a wealth of strange, organic sounds and then manipulating them and bending them into the score. Unlike what most mainstream reviewers may say, this is nothing new in the area of film music. Low budget horror film composers have been manipulating sounds for years, producing a very similar result to what Reznor finally came out with. De-tuned piano, razors on strings, distorted sounds of various appliances, etc. make up the foundation for the majority of Girl with the Dragon Tattoo.
Despite all the sound design and strange effects in the score, there are a few tracks that show some promise of a slightly more mature Reznor. "What if We Could", "Please Take Your Hand Away", "Parrallel Universe with Alternate Outcome" and "A Pair of Doves" show a slight glimmer of light and instrumental sanity among all the bleak sound design and textures. Yet even with these less abrasive tracks, an overall feeling of gloom still hangs over everything.
Still, the main things that bring the album down are the lack of identifiable themes/motifs and the extreme length of the various tracks and overall album for the commercial release. Unlike with The Social Network, Dragon Tattoo at least has a consistent overall mood which aids the listening experience greatly. Unfortunately, the torturous running time (at nearly 3 straight hours) practically kills any good in the package.
A short promo of the score was released before the mammoth commercial album, which contained 6 tracks totaling around half an hours worth of music from the film. This release is really what should have been the commercial album, as it is the perfect sampler of Reznor's work without overstaying its welcome... which the commercial release does within two tracks.
Closing Thoughts:
Despite producing two rather unfortunate albums, I do feel that if given more creative license and allowed to go his own way (instead of being guided around by Fincher), that Reznor might be a great film score composer. Buried beneath all the sound design and dark, brooding atmospheres, there seems to be an intelligent composer that knows how to use sounds... unfortunately he just hasn't been given the chance to really shine.
As is, if you want to hear the best these two works have to offer (which isn't terribly much), then go for the pieces I mentioned. As a whole, these are two rather weak scores even by experimental soundtrack standards. Approach with caution... unless you are a Reznor fanboy in which case what I say means nothing, apparently.
Score:
The Social Network= 1/2 out of 5
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo= 1 1/2 out of 5


. Young also has ventured into action films with scores to Hard Rain and Spider-Man 3, so the blending of Gothic horror and action film sensibilities into one score seemed the ideal blend.



